May 18, 2004 | The
Man With No Name actually had a name - and a nickname - when
Sergio Leone's The Good, The Bad and the Ugly galloped into
theaters throughout Italy in 1966. By the time the movie arrived
in the United States, however, Clint Eastwood's sharp-shooting,
cheroot-chewing antihero was established as anonymous.
And the movie itself - the final chapter of a "Spaghetti Western"
trilogy that Leone began with A Fistful of Dollars (1964)
and continued with For a Few Dollars More (1965) - was 20
minutes shorter.
Blame it on United Artists, the original U.S. distributor
of Leone's revisionist masterworks. Even though Eastwood's
character is referred to by name in each film - Joe (Fistful),
Monco (Few More), Joe or "Blondie" (Good, Bad and Ugly) --
UA executives chose to pique interest by dubbing him The Man
With No Name in trailers, posters and newspaper ads while
releasing English-dubbed versions of the three Italian-produced
films back to back between February 1967 and January 1968.
The movies were hits, and the no-name moniker has remained
part of the legend ever since.
The
same UA decision-makers trimmed 20 minutes from Good, Bad
and Ugly, figuring that would make the movie more accessible,
and less exhausting, for American audiences. Some of the deleted
footage was included as bonus material when MGM Home Entertainment
first released the sprawling epic on DVD in 1998. (MGM, which
merged with UA decades ago, currently controls much of the
UA film library.) Even then, however, the long-missing scenes
were not fully re-integrated into the narrative. Rather, they
simply were bunched together and presented -- with the original
Italian soundtrack -- as a separate "special feature."
But now there's good news for Western fans and Leone aficionados:
A newly restored and virtually complete version of The Good,
The Bad and the Ugly finally is available in the United States.
Originally prepared for airing on the American Movie Classics
cable network, then briefly showcased in a handful of U.S.
theaters, the three-hour magnum opus has been released as
a "Collectors Edition" DVD.
The restoration was a labor of love for John Kirk, an MGM
film archivist who fondly recalls seeing Fistful of Dollars
and For a Few Dollars More during their original theatrical
runs in his native Houston.
"I kind of hate to admit this," Kirk says, "but The Good,
The Bad and the Ugly was the only one of the Leone movies
I didn't see while I was growing up. In fact, I didn't see
it until I started working on this project. But I already
knew that it was every bit as important as the other two in
terms of having a great impact on movie history."
Throughout the entire trilogy, Sergio Leone (1929-89) took
the conventions of traditional sagebrush sagas and pushed
them to unprecedented extremes of graphic violence and seriocomic
cynicism. By doing so, he more or less invented a new subgenre
- the so-called "Spaghetti Western" - in which old rules did
not apply, and new attitudes propelled heroes and villains
alike. Originally derided by some critics as blood-soaked
pastiches and genre-defiling follies - the term "Spaghetti
Western" initially was coined as a dismissive put-down - Leone's
films long ago attained respectability for their own considerable
merits, and for inspiring such action filmmakers as John Carpenter,
Sam Peckinpah, John Woo, Walter Hill, Quentin Tarantino and
Robert Rodriguez.
Clint Eastwood - who achieved international superstardom after
appearing in Fistful of Dollars and its sequels - often has
claimed that Leone "operacized" the Western. The description
is apt, given the director's penchant for stylistic overstatement
in all three films. Time and again, you see self-consciously
ritualized gunfights that intercut immense wide shots of wary
antagonists and intense close-ups of their squinty eyes. Everything
is overlaid with Ennio Morricone's alternately twangy and
thunderous music, and protracted by pauses sufficiently pregnant
to produce quintuplets.
"But The Good, The Bad and the Ugly went much, much further
than the other two," Kirk says. "In fact, it reminded me of
something by David Lean. It was that big a movie, that wide
a canvas.
" Set in the wilds of Texas during the Civil War, Good, Bad
and Ugly traces the interactions and machinations of three
avaricious rogues as they hunt for a buried stash of stolen
gold.
The "good" Joe (Eastwood) knows the name on a tombstone that
marks where the booty is buried. But "ugly" Tuco (Eli Wallach),
a wily Mexican rapscallion, knows where to find the graveyard
where the tombstone is located. Although the unwilling allies
suspect the worst of each other - and with good reason - they
reluctantly join forces to claim the glittering prize. Unfortunately,
their journey repeatedly is impeded by the inconvenient clashes
of Union and Confederate armies. Even more unfortunately,
they are hotly pursued by the "bad" Setenza (Lee Van Cleef),
a.k.a. Angel Eyes, a cold-hearted villain who's eager to make
a killing, one way or the other.
Kirk first heard of the 20-minute gap in Leone's original
scenario when a colleague prepared the '98 DVD. "At one point,"
Kirk says, "he casually said something like, ''You know, it's
really too bad that the movie was cut for U.S. release.' Well,
that's the kind of statement that always makes my ears prick
up. I couldn't help thinking, 'How dare they! What's the mater?
They didn't think we're as good or a smart as the Europeans?'
And that's when I decided to investigate, to see if I could
restore the film."
Working through the Cineteca Nazionale in Italy, Kirk managed
to obtain the best available negative of the original Italian
version. "But it's a good thing I was a language major at
the University of Texas," Kirk says, "because we never were
able to locate an English version of the original shooting
script to guide us. I wound up having to translate an Italian
script on my own."
American Movie Classics provided financing for the project
in December 2002 - with the proviso that Kirk complete his
work within a seven-week period, prior to a locked-in airdate.
"I usually have anywhere from three to eight months to finish
a project like this," Kirk says. "But, fortunately, I'd already
done a lot of homework when AMC came through. In fact, about
six weeks before we got the green light, I had to go to New
York on other business, and that's when my boss suggested
I record Eli Wallach to dub the new scenes. He told me, 'Look,
this guy is like 87 years old. Even if we don't have the money
for the whole project right now, we better get him on tape
while we still can.'"
Voiceover artist Simon Prescott was hired to record English
dialogue for the late, great Lee Van Cleef.
"But Clint Eastwood wanted to record his own dialogue," Kirk
says. "And that was terrific, because, frankly, I'm not sure
there would have been much point in doing this if he wasn't
interested in helping out. But he sent word to us that he
thought the restoration was a great idea.
"The trouble is, when we finally got up and running, he was
shooting Mystic River in Boston. And that did toss us into
a panic for a while. But it turned out that he had to be in
Los Angeles for a couple of days, so he agreed to come in
on a Saturday morning - the Saturday before Christmas, as
a matter of fact - for a half-hour. Fortunately, he only had
a handful of lines to do. Because, remember, he doesn't really
talk that much in the movie anyway."
"Of course, the one thing that was impossible to do, even
though we really did do our best, was precisely match the
quality of the voices (in the restored footage). Because,
obviously, Clint was like thirtysomething when he made the
movie, and now he's seventysomething. It wasn't as much of
a problem with Eli Wallach, because he was already middle-aged
when he made the film. Clint's voice was a little harder to
equalize. But you know what? We felt the real fans would want
to hear the real voices in any event."
Those fans should be delighted by the addition of "lost scenes"
that clarify fuzzy plot transitions and provide revealing
character details. "For example," Kirk says, "we've put a
scene back in the movie where you see Lee Van Cleef's character
going to a Confederate camp and being stunned by all the devastation
there. It's one of the few moments where you feel he has any
sort of compassion at all.
"And we've finally cleared up something that apparently has
always confused some people. You know that scene where Tuco
seems to suddenly have three gunfighters helping him hunt
down Blondie? Well, we've restored the scene that shows how
Tuco recruited these guys - tricked them, really, into working
for him. Actually, this is one of the few scenes in the entire
movie where Tuco demonstrates any kind of intelligence. I
mean, he's going up against Clint Eastwood, for heaven's sake,
and he knows he'd better get some backup help. It doesn't
end up working, of course, but at least he's smart enough
to make the effort."
Kirk insists that his restored edition of Leone's classic
is "not intended as a replacement" for the version available
since 1968 in the United States. "In fact," he says, "that
other version is still available on video, and we've still
got prints of the other version. We just wanted to give people
the picture how it would have existed if UA had not made the
cuts that it required to be made.
"And I have to say, nothing pleased me more than when Alberto
Grimaldi, the original producer of the film, who helped us
so much during the restoration, told me: 'Finally, this is
the version that Sergio would have wanted you to see. I only
wish he could have been here to see it himself.'"
|